Book with us
—up to 10% cheaper
than on Booking.com
Check rooms and rates
From298US$ /night
Check-in
13Jan2026Select date
Check-out
14Jan2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Hotel

Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040
-
Near the beaches
Guest rating
3.5
/10

Sugar Pie Suite Key West hotel gives quick access to the arts theater "Red Barn Theatre", which is situated merely a 5-minute walk away. Offering a swimming pool along with cycling and fishing, this Key West inn is just 0.8 km from the downtown commercial zoned Duval Street.

Location

The hotel is located a mere 650 metres from The Oldest House Historical Place Museum and right around the corner from the Curry Mansion. From Sugar Pie Suite hotel it will take approximately 15 minutes to walk to the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.

The accommodation is also situated 400 m from Caroline Street & Simonton Street bus stop. The distance to Key West International airport is 5 km.

Rooms

The rooms at the Sugar Pie Key West have Wi-Fi and a multi-channel TV, along with coffee/tea making machines for your convenience. An ironing set and climate control are featured for guests' comfort.

Eat & Drink

Cuban Coffee Queen with Cuban cuisine is located in close proximity to this Key West hotel.

“The hotel's location stands out, a true asset for exploring Key West. While offering a clean room, the hotel presents a simple, no-frills experience. In my opinion, it serves as a practical base for those prioritizing location above all else.”
Hotel logo
James DavidEditor-in-Chief at Dogfriendly-hotels
View all

Select your room type

The hotel provides many room choices—family rooms, doubles, and pet-friendly suites—with breakfast, free cancellation, and special offers
Studio
2 persons
19 m² 
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning

Rates & availability calendar

See current prices and availability for your chosen dates!

Facilities

Hotels feature amenities designed to keep both you and your pet comfortable

General

  • No smoking on site
  • Wi-Fi
  • Pets allowed

Sports & Fitness

  • Water sports
  • Cycling
  • Golf course
  • Fishing

Spa & Leisure

  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Aqua park
  • Garden area

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Patio
  • Tea and coffee facilities
  • Ironing facilities

Bathroom

  • Free toiletries
Show more

Hotel location

Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040
Map view
Caroline Street 537, Key West, Florida, United States, 33040
Nearby
Square
Mallory Square
580 m
Museum
Truman Little White House
560 m
Aquarium
Key West Aquarium
530 m
Museum
Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum
530 m
511 Caroline St
Curry Mansion
140 m
Event hall
San Carlos Institute Casa Cuba
550 m
Museum
Ripley's Believe It or Not
400 m
Garden
Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden
450 m
Gallery
The Studios of Key West
170 m
Museum
Mel Fisher Maritime Heritage Museum
440 m
Garden
Audubon House and Tropical Gardens
440 m
Mallory Square between Whitehead and Wall sts.
Memorial Sculpture Garden
520 m
Square
Key West-Florida Keys Historical Military Memorial
420 m
Gallery
7 Artists & Friends Gallery
60 m
Gallery
Gallery on Greene
130 m
Church
Saint Paul's Episcopal Church of Key West
370 m
410 Caroline St Between Duval and Whitehead Streets
Key West Pirates Well
240 m
490 Whitehead St
US 1 Mile Marker 0
580 m
534 Fleming St
KEPart Studio-Gallery
320 m
519 Duval St
Peter Lik Gallery Key West
410 m
Restaurants
Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe
250 m
200 Elizabeth St Corner of Greene & Elizabeth Street
Garbo's Grill
280 m
409 Caroline Street
Key West Key Lime Pie Co
220 m
511 Greene St
Shorty's Market
270 m
215 Duval St
Hot Dog Lounge
180 m
corner of Caroline St and Duval St
Paradise Pizza
250 m
503 Greene St
Angelina's Pizzeria
290 m
208 Duval St Ricks & Durty Harrys Complex
Sweet Pete's
260 m
511 Greene St
Fisherman's Cafe
350 m
205 Elizabeth St Unit D
Boardwalk Frozen Custard
320 m
335 Duval St
Explore Key West
Explore Key West
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Duval Street
10 minutes' walk
Vibrant street known for shops, bars, and restaurants, perfect for people-watching and Key West culture.
The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum
15 minutes' walk
Former residence of author Ernest Hemingway, featuring lush gardens and guided tours illuminating his life.
Mallory Square
8 minutes' walk
Famous waterfront plaza known for sunset celebrations, food vendors, and local artisans showcasing their crafts.
Key West Aquarium
7 minutes' walk
Interactive marine exhibits highlights local sea life, offering touch tanks and feeding sessions with sea turtles.
Water Sports
10 minutes' walk
Thrilling options including snorkeling and kayaking available through local rental services near the hotel.
Yoga Classes
5 minutes' walk
Relaxing yoga sessions held outdoors in nearby parks, perfect for rejuvenating body and mind amidst nature.
Garbo's Grill
4 minutes' walk
Casual eatery famous for its fish tacos and gourmet burgers, located in a charming outdoor setting.
Key West Key Lime Pie Co
3 minutes' walk
Local favorite known for its authentic key lime pie, offering a delightful tasting experience in a cozy atmosphere.
Mallory Square
8 minutes' walk
Location for sunset celebrations with live music, street performers, and local crafts, ideal for all-age enjoyment.
The Green Parrot Bar
10 minutes' walk
Lively bar featuring live music and karaoke nights, known for its friendly atmosphere and diverse crowd.
Local transport and travel tips
City Centre
Key West27 min  ·  2.2 km
Airports
Key West International Airport (EYW)10 min  ·  6.4 km
Want access to early-bird pet-friendly hotel deals?
Access exclusive discounts today!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-23:59
Check-out
until 10 am
Guest Parking
No parking available.
Internet
is available in for free.
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
FAQs
About Sugar Pie Suite
What is the check-in and check-out policy at Sugar Pie Suite?
Check-in is at 16:00 and check-out is by 10:00.
How far is Sugar Pie Suite from the nearest airport?
Sugar Pie Suite is located 4 km from Key West International Airport.
What amenities does Sugar Pie Suite offer for guests?
Guests can enjoy an outdoor swimming pool, fully equipped kitchenettes, and free Wi-Fi throughout the property.
Which popular attractions are near Sugar Pie Suite?
Nearby attractions include Mallory Square (0.5 km), Duval Street (1 km), and the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum (2 km).
What room amenities are available at Sugar Pie Suite?
Rooms feature air conditioning, a patio, a microwave, a fridge, cable TV, and free toiletries.
What dining options are available near Sugar Pie Suite?
Nearby restaurants include Fogarty's (0.5 km), Conch Republic Seafood Company (0.5 km), and The Breakfast Club (0.5 km).
What activities can guests enjoy at Sugar Pie Suite?
Guests can participate in cycling, fishing, and water sports facilities on-site.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.
Check-in
13Jan2026Select date
Check-out
14Jan2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Need more options?
Check Top hotels near Sugar Pie Suite
Creme Brulee Suite Key West Beds photo
Mobile-only price

Creme Brulee Suite Key West

7.9
Very good23 reviews
0m from property
USD 223USD 200
per night
Honey Bun Hideaway Hotel Key West Beds photo
Mobile-only price

Honey Bun Hideaway Hotel Key West

7.0
Very good1 review
0m from property
USD 237USD 213
per night
Key Lime Cottage Key West Room photo
Mobile-only price

Key Lime Cottage Key West

7.0
Very good2 reviews
0m from property
USD 363USD 326
per night